Patreon banner
Patreon banner
Matt's Movie Reviews logo
HOME REVIEWS PODCAST FEATURES TOP TEN VIDEO TOP MOVIES ABOUT
Facebook logo Youtube logo Linkedin logo Reddit logo Instagram logo MeWe logo RSS logo
Apple Podcast logo Spotify logo Google Podcasts image Amazon logo Podbean logo Stitcher logo
THE MANY SAINTS OF NEWARK (2021)
Many Saints of Newark poster

CAST
ALESSANDRO NIVOLA
JON BERNTHAL
MICHELA DE ROSSI
JOEY DIAZ
VERA FARMIGA
MICHAEL GANDOLFINI
GERMAR TERRELL GARDNER
ALEXANDRA INTRATOR
RAY LIOTTA
JOHN MAGARO
BILLY MAGNUSSEN
LESLIE ODOM JR.
GABRIELLA PIAZZA
COREY STOLL

BASED ON CHARACTERS BY
DAVID CHASE

SCREENPLAY BY
DAVID CHASE
LAWRENCE KONNER

CINEMATOGRAPHY BY
KRAMER MORGENTHAU

EDITED BY
CHRISTOPHER TELLEFSEN

PRODUCED BY
DAVID CHASE
LAWRENCE KONNER
NICOLE LAMBERT

DIRECTED BY
ALAN TAYLOR

GENRE
CRIME
DRAMA

RATED
AUS:MA
UK:15
USA:R

RUNTIME
120 MIN

 

 

 

 

 

 


Many Saints of Newark image

With its lack of focus and scattershot structure, The Many Saints of Newark fails to live up to the pedigree of The Sopranos series.

Although written and produced by The Sopranos creator David Chase and featuring the alluring tagline of “Who Made Tony Soprano?”, The Many Saints of Newark proves to be a frustrating experience of characters never given their due and scenarios that go nowhere. Younger versions of beloved characters are played as caricatures, while new characters are easily forgettable in their blandness.

The film begins, befuddlingly, with slain The Sopranos regular Christopher Moltisanti (Michael Imperioli) providing narration beyond the grave. He introduces two key figures: his father Dickie Moltisanti (Alessandro Nivola), and his uncle and eventual murderer Anthony Soprano (Michael Gandolfini, son of James Gandolfini who played Tony Soprano to great acclaim.)

The stage is set for a mentor-style mob movie in the vein of A Bronx Tale or Donnie Brasco, yet such a thing is too easy for Chase. No, irritation and complication are the key to Chase’s artistry, the very same artistry which saw The Sopranos cut to black in a conclusion that still has fans scratching their heads.

Rather than develop the relationship between Moltisanti and Soprano, Chase instead places “Uncle Dickie” into multiple plot-threads: an affair with his young Italian immigrant step-mother Giuseppina (Michela De Rossi); frequent visits to his jailbird uncle Salvatore (Ray Liotta) where he seeks advice on how to do “a good dead”; and a turf war with Harold McBrayer (Leslie Odom Jr), a black gangster empowered by the civil rights movement to make a name for himself.

The latter, which also heavily features the impact of the 1967 Newark Riots, feels particularly out of place, and does little to further flesh out the Sopranos world, of which The Many Saints of Newark feels more link a splintered offshoot than the foundational piece promised.

Director Alan Taylor (who helmed several episodes of The Sopranos) is unable to make these fragments into a compelling whole. It is as if a limited series is in an editing bay somewhere and this is a compilation of the “best bits” strung together with the subtlety of a Bada-Bing! stripper in a church.

Performances are mostly fine, with Vera Farmiga as the antagonistic Livia Soprano, and young Michael Gandolfini doing his late father proud, the highlights. The production design is also a standout, taking the audience back to late 1960s New Jersey and all its complicated glory.

What The Many Saints of Newark does not do is bring anything of worth to the substance of the Sopranos legacy. If anything, it brings it down a notch, and that is a damn shame.

**

 

 

RELATED CONTENT
Irishman image Gotti image

.
APPROVED CRITIC AT
Rotten Tomatoes Logo

Created and Edited by Matthew Pejkovic / Contact: mattsm@mattsmoviereviews.net
Logo created by Colony Graphic Design / Copyright © Matthew Pejkovic

Patreon banner
Patreon banner